I think the official rule is no photshopping. Unless you consider the rules to be something else. There is alot of grey over ones people have asked to have taken down the nudes or the cocaine pictures. If a member asks to have it taken down action isn't always taken on the posting member. I'm not sure that posting material that has already been posted is an offense. I looked at it more like, post some classic photos people have put up thread. Like a photo album. I didn't post pictures of people to make fun of them.....well maybe that one in the thong

was silly.
But I can see where there is some uncertainties.
What did you believe the rules to be on reposting pictures that are meant to recall a time of when it was posted, rather than the reposting of photoshopped pictures....? See where the confusion sets in? Is it okay to repost a pict from before we didn't want photo shopping, but yes its not okay to photoshop now.....ect add confusion.
If i posted pictures that upset anyone I appologize.
I hope you see why its hard to make a simple call sometimes. We don't have annual congress to review the rules.