Thread: Higher Power
View Single Post
Old 05-14-2008, 06:32 PM   #26 (permalink)
Vik*star*
YaHookan
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Auckland
Posts: 149
Thanks: 21
Thanked 22 Times in 22 Posts
""You asked, what is, can't exist? Huh? Before I was born, I didn't exist. After I die, I won't exist.""

The problem with your argument is, if we didn't exist before, then how come we magically came into existence? I mean non-existence should be non existence, what this argument is doing is correlating non-existance and existance which is not possible. Here I'll try to explain in simpler terms:

Lets take non-existance as place A
And existance as place B

Now you were in place A before you were born
Now mum and Dad produces you and you come in to Place B
You die and go back into place A

This is where argument dies: What makes me/you think that we can't come back to place B again.

The thing is if existance can come from non-existance which is what above argument is basically stating, then after life is possible even if you are non-existant after death.

And if you don't correlate non-existance and existance, that would mean we always existed before birth and hence we will exist after death.
Vik*star* is offline   Reply With Quote