DdC

Washington, D.C. -- Jonathan Magbie was a 27-year-old man who was paralyzed from the neck down as a result of a childhood accident. Although he had never been convicted of a criminal offense and although he required private nursing care for as much as 20 hours a day, Magbie was given a 10-day sentence in the D.C. jail in September 2004 by D.C. Superior Court Judge Judith E. Retchin for possession of a marijuana cigarette. He died in city custody four days later. His story has been the subject of several previous columns.

Earlier this week Edward D. Reiskin, deputy mayor for public safety and justice, provided D.C. Council members David Catania (I-At Large) and Phil Mendelson (D-At Large), chairmen, respectively, of the council's Health and Judiciary committees, with the findings from the D.C. Department of Corrections (DOC) investigation into the care provided Magbie from Sept. 20 to Sept. 24, 2004.

Actually, to call the Corrections Department's report an "investigation" is like describing a BB gun as an AK-47. The eight-page document produced by the department's Office of Internal Affairs attempts to explain away a more extensive and highly critical investigation into Magbie's death that D.C. Inspector General Charles J. Willoughby conducted last October. Willoughby's report and the lawsuit filed by the American Civil Liberties Union and two lawyers on behalf of Magbie's mother, Mary R. Scott, are more credible. They provide real insight into Magbie's neglectful treatment by the criminal justice system.

Now to the Department of Corrections "investigation." The findings were dutifully and uncritically transmitted to the council by Reiskin, who, incidentally, complained to lawmakers that "the investigation was hindered by legal advice provided to [the contractor medical staff] by its counsel not to release any information to DOC regarding this issue due to pending litigation."
That clampdown on salient information did not, however, stop Corrections from arriving on the scene after Willoughby completed his extensive investigation and producing an Internal Affairs document that exonerates or at least gives a virtuous appearance to many of the actions by staff and employees at the corrections facility where Magbie was confined. But even Corrections couldn't cover all the participants with whitewash.

In some cases, Corrections' critical findings were accompanied by recommended disciplinary actions that have all the harshness of a beating with a wet noodle.

Internal Affairs Found:

* There were instances in which Magbie's medical care was not documented. But the nurses culpable in the acts of omission couldn't be identified because the medical contractor, paid by the Corrections Department with D.C. tax dollars, wouldn't give access to the contractor's employees.

* The associate medical director of the jail where Magbie was confined knew about Magbie's vulnerable medical condition and that he needed acute care immediately, but failed to notify higher-ups. The associate medical director, the report noted, resigned last October. Undeterred, Corrections bravely directed the medical contractor to "place a letter of reprimand in the doctor's Official Personnel File" and to determine "any other appropriate disciplinary action to be pursued against the doctor."

* Correctional and medical staff provided written memos to the Corrections Department director stating that they never saw Magbie's cell door locked while he was in the unit. (It should have remained unlocked, because there was no way that Magbie, a quadriplegic, could reach the emergency button.) Corrections discovered information that contradicted the staff-written memos: Magbie's cell door had in fact been locked, in violation of doctor's orders. For their lying, Corrections fearlessly instructed the warden, disciplinary action was to be taken against the two officers and a disciplinary letter placed in the personnel file of each.

* A physician in the Corrections facility housing Magbie told the inspector general that he was unaware of Magbie's return from Greater Southeast Community Hospital, where he had been taken as an emergency patient during his first night in jail. It turns out, the Corrections report noted, that the physician did see Magbie upon his return. That physician, thundered the Corrections report, "will no longer be permitted on DOC premises . . . this action is to take place posthaste."

As for the Corrections Department's decision to keep the ventilator-dependent Magbie confined for four days to the Correctional Treatment Facility, where no ventilator or appropriate medical care was available?

The "investigation," done by Corrections staff and passed along by Reiskin, gave the rest of the nurses, physicians and staff a pass.

Judge Retchin? She was cleared by the Commission on Judicial Disabilities and Tenure.

Say this much for ol' D.C., it takes care of its own.

If justice is to be had in this case, it won't be found in D.C. agencies. Better to look to the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. That's where the Jonathan Magbie lawsuit is filed.

Note: Non related portion removed.
Glossing Over Mistreatment in The Magbie Case By Colbert I. King
Source: Washington Post April 07, 2006
Contact: letterstoed@washpost .com * Website

Related Articles

A Searing Portrait of Abuse

'Top-Floor' Treatment in D.C.

ACLU and Local Attorneys File Lawsuit



Judge and Executioner

A Judicial Crime - the killing of Jonathan Magbie

Young Jonathan Magbie in 1982 (paralyzed from the chin down), meeting President Reagan during the proclamation of National Respiratory Therapy Week. Last month, he was sentenced to jail for marijuana possession. It turned out to be a death sentence.

DdC

A Searing Portrait of Abuse By Colbert I. King
Washington Post November 25, 2005*Washington, D.C.
This is the 12th column to be written about Jonathan Magbie, a 27-year-old man who was paralyzed from the neck down at age 4 after being struck by a drunk driver. Magbie lived at home with his mother, needed private nursing care at least 20 hours a day and was totally dependent upon others because he couldn't use any of his limbs. He got around in a motorized wheelchair that he operated with his mouth, and his breathing was aided by a tracheotomy tube and an implanted diaphragmatic pacemaker.
Read More... http://www.cannabisnews.com/news/thread21336.shtml



The DrugWar, in micrososm
It mainly attacks minorities (Mr. Magbie was Black if you're not familiar with the case)
AS IT WAS ORIGINALLY DESIGNED TO
(see http://www.drugwar.com/blackfiends.shtm and
http://www.drugwar.com/whitehope.shtm ).

The Racist Ganjawar

DEAth Sentence for Small-Time Crime

''Sen. George V. Voinovich, the Senate's watchdog for Washington, D.C., affairs, said yesterday he would try to block a new Washington city law allowing the medical use of marijuana.'' 1999 cannabisnews.com



THE BUSH-CHENEY DRUG EMPIRE

`Efforts to legalize marijuana for medical purposes in the District were blocked yesterday when a federal appeals court overturned, without explanation, an earlier court ruling that had cleared the way for the issue to be put before D.C. voters. ... "It is too bad that a three-judge panel was able to thwart the will of tens of thousands of D.C. voters," said Steve Fox, a spokesman for the group. "It is sadder still that this ruling will cause the suffering of seriously ill patients in the city to continue." 2002 cannabisnews.com



Drugwar Lies Linked to Schizophrenia

MMJ Use Advocates Stage Protest at Barr's Office By David Pace
A P Star Tribune October 21, 1999
Supporters of medical marijuana usage blocked the door to Georgia Rep. Bob Barr' s office Thursday to protest his efforts to overturn a District of Columbia referendum that would permit seriously ill people to use marijuana legally if their doctors recommend it.

Cheryl Heart Foundation

Klintoon ask Supreams to Overturn MMJ ruling



If the personal freedoms guaranteed by the Constitution inhibit the government's ability to govern the people, we should look to limit those guarantees.
President Bill Clinton, August 12, 1993

The Drug War Refugees



A diamond in the rough.
posted by lombar on April 09, 2006 at 22:09:57 PT

some dots for why the resistance to the end of the war on drugs is so fierce. About $500 B per year they claim are going thru the US economy yearly. To stop the drug war may crash the US economy.

THE FUTURE OF FOOD
1 hr 28 min 54 sec
Genetically Modified Food ..
53 min 33 sec
Texe Marrs Gulag USA Concen..
1 hr 21 min 31 sec

The Ganjawar is a Product Sold by D.E.A.th to Profit Fascists

Policing For Profit: The Drug War's Hidden Economic Agenda

U.S. law enforcement spends $7.5 to $10 billion annually enforcing marijuana laws.
According to the FBI, 720,000 Americans were arrested on marijuana charges in 2001.
(Keith Stroup, (NORML)

A little off topic, but interesting
posted by John Tyler on December 13, 2005
There was a strange article in the newspaper today. In Appalachia, it seems that quite a number of the elderly, in order to make ends meet, have taken to selling part of their prescription pain meds for profit. This is really quite sad, since they don’t have enough to live on, and no other way of generating an income, they are practically forced by economic circumstance to do this. Then the weird Drug War part comes in. The cops are now arresting these old people and throwing them in jail. I mean, how fast is someone with a walker going to be able to move. But, on the upside they can now be provided them food, shelter, and medical care (pain meds again) at government expense while in jail, a much bigger government expense by the way, than there would be if they could receive adequate care in the first place. Isn’t that something, jail as an assisted living facility? I wonder if anyone will figure that out. No, probably not.



The Business of Genocide: by Michael Thad Allen
The SS, Slave Labor, and the Concentration Camps

"fascism - A system of government that exercises a dictatorship of the extreme right, typically through the merging of state and business leadership, together with belligerent nationalism."
American Heritage Dictionary, 1983

Slave Labor Means Big Bucks For U.S. Corporations
UNICORE

Marijuana Arrests For Year 2004: 771,608
NORML: Special Report*October 17, 2005 Washington, D.C. USA
Record High, FBI Report Reveals
Pot Smokers Arrested In America At A Rate Of One Every 41 Seconds
Washington, DC: Police arrested an estimated 771,608 persons for marijuana violations in 2004, according to the Federal Bureau of Investigation's annual Uniform Crime Report, released today.
Read More... http://www.cannabisnews.com/news/thread21198.shtml



YEAR MARIJUANA ARRESTS
2004 771,608 * 2000 734,498 * 1996 641,642
2003 755,187 * 1999 704,812 * 1995 588,963
2002 697,082 * 1998 682,885 * 1994 499,122
2001 723,627 * 1997 695,200 * 1993 380,689

Dr. Heath/Tulane Study, 1974
The Hype: Brain Damage and Dead Monkeys (Jack Herer)

Soon after xDrug Czar Carlton Turner left office, Nancy Reagan recommended that no corporation be permitted to do business with the Federal government without having a urine purity policy in place to show their loyalty. Just as G. Gordon Liddy went into high-tech corporate security after his disgrace, Carlton Turner became a rich man in what has now become a huge growth industry: urine-testing. (Mandatory tasting many of those arrested, usually along with "treatment" corporations as part of a plea bargain. More schools are being coerced into mandatory tasting or lose highway and/or school funding.)

Corporatism also exploits the Drug War

Fascism 101: Federal Marijuana Monopoly Challenged

U.S. Drug Agents Raid 13 Medical Marijuana Sites By Jeff McDonald
Source: SignOnSanDiego.com San Diego, CA December 12, 2005 *
Federal agents fanned out across San Diego County on Monday, executing simultaneous search warrants on 13 medical marijuana dispensaries that have been selling pot to sick and dying patients. No one was arrested on suspicion of drug-dealing, officials said, but agents seized dozens of pounds of high-grade marijuana along with equipment, computers, patient files and other materials inside the storefront offices.
Read More... http://www.cannabisnews.com/news/thread21376.shtml

DdC

Glossing Over Mistreatment in The Magbie Case

Save Bernie's Farm By Anna Thompson
On August 28, 2002, Bernie Ellis’s farm was raided by the Tennessee Marijuana Eradication Task Force, a force that included both state and federal law enforcement officers. During the ten hours the Task Force was on Bernie’s farm, two helicopters and ten ground troops combed his land, searched his home and out-buildings and confiscated farm supplies, files from his work as a public health consultant and his computer. The Task Force found a small amount of cannabis in Bernie’s home, 20-25 plants that were four to six feet tall and a number of small “clones” (under 12 inches tall) – all ready to harvest. To their surprise, they also found a proposal solicited by the New Mexico Governor’s Office for Bernie to help that state establish and operate a state-operated medical cannabis production facility.
Complete Article: http://tinyurl.com/cqgpu

The Invisible Prohibition

"Behind the ostensible government sits enthroned an invisible government owing no allegiance and acknowledging no responsibility to the people. To destroy this invisible government, to befoul the unholy alliance between corrupt business and corrupt politics is the first task of the statesmanship of today."
- President Theodore Roosevelt

Drug War Weapons April 7, 2006

S.D. Family Seeks The Right To Grow Hemp

Switching cotton fields to hemp fields would improve: the quality of our soil, the durability of our clothes, the safety of our ground source water, the quality of our air, and the preservation of forests cut for paper (not to mention saving hundreds of thousands of lives prematurely ended by disease caused by pollution) In 1993, two hundred and fifty thousand tons of pesticides were used to grow cotton world-wide.

LAKOTA, HEMP, AND GLOBALIZATION

DEA Set To Battle Pot Advocates Over Hemp Use

These pesticides wash into streams and rivers, destroying eco-systems and poisoning human water supplies. Today the water supplies of many large cities are contaminated. Many of the vegetables we eat and clothes we wear contain pesticide residues. We must develop and utilize sustainable technologies if we want to survive and prosper in the next millenium. Hemp is a perfect sustainable raw material for thousands of products. Textiles, cosmetics, building materials, fuel and food can all be made from hemp.

Poison Inc. Pesticides v Hemp

Don't get sucked in by former ONDCP staff

"Not only are we here to protect the public from vicious criminals in the street
but also to protect the public from harmful ideas."
Robert Ingersoll, first director of the DEA

A Drug Warmongers Toll on the Americas



Spoils of Drug War Forfeitures Prove Too Lucrative

Government Property Seizures out of Control

Federal and State Police Kill Owner for Rainbow Farm
On the Friday before Labor Day 2001, rather than face a bail revocation hearing for holding an unauthorized marijuana rally last August Grover "Tom" Crosslin and Rolland Rohm retreated to Rainbow Farm...

Drug Ruling Worries Some in Public Housing

Jive Souder: Drug Sentencing Reform Act

Higher Education Act
In 1998, Congress passed an amendment authored by Rep. Mark Souder that denies federal financial aid to any student with a drug conviction. Given the racially disproportionate enforcement of drug laws, the Souder-amendment has a greater impact on people of color than whites. Also, the Souder-amendment only punishes working class and middle class students since wealthy students do not rely on financial aid to attend college.

Food Stamps Become a Weapon in the War on Drugs

__________________