LetsPlayYourWay

Cannabis row drugs adviser sacked

The UK's chief drugs adviser has been sacked by Home Secretary Alan Johnson, after criticising government policies.

Professor David Nutt, head of the Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs, criticised the decision to reclassify cannabis to Class B from C.

He accused ministers of devaluing and distorting evidence and said drugs classification was being politicised.

The home secretary said he had "lost confidence" in his advice and asked him to step down.

The Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs (ACMD) is the UK's official drugs advisory body.

Following his sacking, Prof Nutt told the BBC he stood by his claim that cannabis should not be a Class B drug, based on its effects.

He described his sacking as a "serious challenge to the value of science in relation to the government".

MARK EASTON'S UK
“ We are witnessing a collision between science and politics - there may be significant fall-out ”
Mark Easton BBC's home editor

And he denied that he had been trying to undermine the government's policies on drugs.

"I am disappointed because, to be honest, all I was trying to do was help. I wasn't challenging the government," said the former adviser.

"We can help them. We can give them very good advice, and it would be much more simpler if they took that advice rather than getting tangled up in other sorts of messages which frankly really do confuse the public."

Prof Nutt said he was not prepared to "mislead" the public about the effects of drugs in order to convey a moral "message" on the government's behalf.

Earlier this week Prof Nutt used a lecture at King's College, London, to attack what he called the "artificial" separation of alcohol and tobacco from illegal drugs.

The professor said smoking cannabis created only a "relatively small risk" of psychotic illness.

Phil Willis MP, chairman of the science and technology select committee, said he would write to the home secretary to ask for clarification as to why Prof David Nutt had been sacked "at a time when independent scientific advice to government is essential".

"It is disturbing if an independent scientist should be removed for reporting sound scientific advice," he said.

Public concern over the links between high-strength cannabis, known as skunk, and mental illness led the government to reclassify cannabis to Class B last year.

In the past, Prof Nutt has also claimed that taking ecstasy is no more dangerous than riding a horse.

In a letter, the home secretary wrote: "I cannot have public confusion between scientific advice and policy and have therefore lost confidence in your ability to advise me as chair of the ACMD.

"I would therefore ask you to step down from the Council with immediate effect."

In his reply, Prof Nutt said he was "disappointed" by the sentiments expressed by Mr Johnson.

He added: "Whilst I accept that there is a distinction between scientific advice and government policy there is clearly a degree of overlap.

"If scientists are not allowed to engage in the debate at this interface then you devalue their contribution to policy making and undermine a major source of carefully considered and evidence-based advice."

'Disgraceful' decision

Shadow home secretary Chris Grayling said the sacking had been "an inevitable decision" after Prof Nutt's "latest ill-judged contribution to the debate".

But Liberal Democrat home affairs spokesman Chris Huhne said the decision to sack the adviser had been "disgraceful".

"What is the point of having independent scientific advice if as soon as you get some advice that you don't like, you sack the person who has given it to you?" he said.

Mr Huhne said if the government did not want to take expert scientific advice, it might as well have "a committee of tabloid newspaper editors to advise on drugs policy".

Similarly, Claudia Rubin from Release - a national centre of expertise on drugs and drugs law - said the expert should not have been penalised.

Cannabis reclassification

"It's a real shame and a real indictment of the government's refusal to take any proper advice on this subject," she said.

And Prof Colin Blakemore, professor of neuroscience at Oxford University and former chief executive of the Medical Research Council, said the government could not expect experts who serve on its independent committees not to voice their concern if the advice they give is rejected.

"I worry that the dismissal of Prof Nutt will discourage academic and clinical experts from offering their knowledge and time to help the government in the future," he said.

Possession of Class B drugs carries a maximum sentence of five years in jail while possession of Class C drugs carries a maximum sentence of two years imprisonment.

In 2004, then Home Secretary David Blunkett had approved the reclassification of cannabis from Class B - which it had been since 1971 - to Class C.

But in 2008, Jacqui Smith announced that she would reverse the 2004 decision and put cannabis back into category B.

The decision was taken despite official advisers recommending against the change.

Ministers said they wanted to make the move as a precautionary measure.
Story from BBC NEWS:
BBC NEWS | UK | Cannabis row drugs adviser sacked

__________________

Flamingnun

Yep

__________________

SpankyMcLankey

omg, at least something is happening though. if only this story could get into mainstream media in the US...

Mercury

Man they're really cracking down across the pond. Whereas in the States it seems like we're actually making headway on the issue. Change we can believe in?

patriot

Tell the truth and get fired. Especially regarding that dangerous marijuana.

__________________
A true patriot is always ready to stand up against his own government.

We can't be using plants that come from the Lord for beneficial purposes. Now hurry up, or we'll be late for church.

The bigger the lie, the more people will believe it.-Adolf Hitler

Legalizing marijuana won't grow our economy-Barack Hussein Obama 2009

ProfessorMurder

(snicker, snicker) "Professor Nutt got sacked?!..."


"-by Secretary Johnson"

__________________
"No contaban con mi astucia!"

Flamingnun

BBC NEWS | UK | UK Politics | Government drugs adviser resigns

__________________

BibleGuy

Right. If a reasonable/rational/scientific opinion doesn't support the political agenda then #!%&@$* its wrong. That's why governments ignore and hide studies that conclude marijuana is harmless, therapeutic, etc. That's why Nixon rejected the Shafer Commission, why judge Young's decision was overruled and why Professor Nutt was sacked.

Flamingnun

BBC NEWS | UK | UK Politics | Second drugs adviser quits post


Another walkout.

__________________

DdC

UK’s Drugs Czar Fired For Marijuana Truths

Gordon Brown defends Nutt sacking DWR
Mr Brown backed Mr Johnson’s decision and defended the right of elected ministers to reject the advice of scientists at times. He said: “On climate change, or health, for example, we take the best scientific advise possible. But in an area like drugs we have to look at it in the round.

Drug Panel Revolt Over Fired Chief Professor David Nutt
UK: MapINC Recent Media Headlines

Johnson Under Fire As More Advisers Threaten to Resign

THERE'S NO POINT IN ADVISERS
IF THEY CAN SAY ONLY WHAT MINISTERS WANT

REMOVAL RISKS DISCOURAGING EXPERTS FROM GIVING OPINION

Treading Fine Line Between Providing Advice - or Policy

Cannabis Confusion Is Labour's Fault, Not Professor Nutt's

Scientists Quit Government Drugs Body Over David Nutt Sacking

Scientists Rebel At Drug Czar Sacking



Drugs Policy: Shooting Up the Messenger

Like Drunks In Denial, MPs Blow Off Truth About Drugs

Removal Risks Discouraging Experts From Giving Opinion

Cannabis Risks Must Not Be Underplayed

Jacob responds to Jon Ferry on David Nutt firings
Jacob Hunter
Mr Ferry… why do you not come out strongly when the RCMP (Or, as it was last week, the OPP) issue press releases with unsubstantiated and alarmist statements about the danger of marijuana cultivation facilities?